Skip to content

Are non-dividend paying stocks just pure speculation?

  • Q&A

Investing in non-dividend paying stocks is sometimes considered more speculative than dividend-paying stocks. This is due to the lack of a reliable, steady income from the stock. The only way to make money from non-dividend paying assets is to rely on an increase in the price. This can be difficult to predict since stock prices are influenced by many different factors, such as economic conditions and market sentiment. Because of this, non-dividend paying stocks can be more volatile and may be more suitable for experienced investors with a greater appetite for risk.

While some investors may be comfortable taking the risk of investing in non-dividend paying stocks in hopes of capital gains, other investors may need a steady stream of income from their investments. In this case, dividend-paying stocks would be a more suitable option since these provide regular dividend payments that can be used as income.

A stock can be considered speculative if there is a great deal of uncertainty as to the future value or income. This is true whether the stock offers a dividend or not. Many high dividend stocks have fooled novice investors into thing they’re getting a solid return for their money, only to see the stock price cut by 50% or more and the underlying company go bankrupt.

Dividends do not define speculative or safe investments.

Regardless of the presence of dividends, it is important for investors to understand the risks associated with investing in stocks and weigh the potential benefits against the risks before making an investment decision.

The Role of Non-Dividend Paying Stocks in a Value Investor’s Portfolio

Non-dividend paying stocks can play an important role in an investment portfolio as they typically offer better potential for capital appreciation over time. Value investors often look for stocks that are undervalued and have potential for growth, which may not necessarily be associated with dividend payments. Non-dividend paying stocks tend to be more volatile, which means there is a better chance to buy them on sale, when the price is below their Intrinsic Value.

Non-dividend paying stocks can also serve as a hedge against inflation and provide diversification benefits.

Pros and Cons of Non-Dividend Paying Stocks

The Pros

The primary appeal of investing in non-dividend paying stocks lies in their potential for strong return on investment. These stocks tend to have lower yields than dividend paying stocks, meaning that investors don’t receive a regular income from the stock. Instead, these stocks are held for the potential for capital appreciation and long-term growth. As such, investors who purchase non-dividend paying stocks are often hoping for the stock to appreciate over time and for them to reap financial returns when they choose to sell the stock at a later date.

In addition, since these stocks are often undervalued and overlooked, investors may be able to purchase them at a lower cost than they otherwise would have been able to if they had invested in a dividend paying stock.

Another pro to investing in stocks that don’t pay a dividend is that you don’t owe any taxes until you sell. Dividends, in contrast, are taxed with every payout (monthly, quarterly, etc). This makes non-dividend paying stocks an excellent choice for people with high incomes and the high tax brackets that come with them. If they hold the stock until they retire, their tax bracket should be lower.

The Cons

Of course, no investment comes without risks, and this is no exception. The biggest risk associated with non-dividend paying stocks is that they are more volatile than dividend paying stocks, meaning that their share prices can change drastically in short periods.

But wait, didn’t I just say that was a pro of investing in non-dividend paying stocks?

Yes, I did. It’s both a pro and a con. If you do your valuations correctly and keep a margin of safety, then you’ll buy the stock at a low and it’s a pro. But if you don’t get the valuation correct or if you get impatient and buy too high, then it is a con.

Analyzing the Risk/Reward of Non-Dividend Paying Stocks

Analyzing the risk/reward of stocks that don’t pay dividends takes a little more effort than evaluating stocks that do produce income for their shareholders. With dividend-paying stocks, investors can use the dividend yield to determine how fast the dividend income will pay back the initial investment cost.

With non-dividend paying stocks, on the other hand, investors must look at a combination of factors to determine if a stock is worth purchasing.

The primary factor to consider when analyzing the risk/reward of non-dividend paying stocks is the company’s growth potential. Investors need to assess the company’s prospects for future growth and profitability, which will determine if the stock price is likely to rise. Fundamental analysis is the primary way of evaluating a company’s potential for value investors.

This requires investors to look at things such as a company’s balance sheet, income statement and cash flow statement in order to gain an understanding of the company’s financial health and prospects for the future. An important factor to consider is the company’s management team; a strong team can often be the difference between success and failure.

Investors must also consider the stock’s valuation. This involves looking at metrics such as price-to-earnings ratio and price-to-book value ratio, as well as factors such as the stock’s liquidity and market capitalization. By comparing these metrics to similar stocks, investors can get a better sense of whether a stock is trading at a reasonable price or if it is overvalued.

Strategies for Investing in Non-Dividend Paying Stocks

Non-dividend paying stocks are a popular option for investors looking to increase their investment portfolio without requiring a steady income stream. While these stocks do not provide an immediate return, they can be a great way to diversify your investments and increase overall returns in the long run.

When it comes to investing in non-dividend paying stocks, the strategy recommended here at Mercury Investing is the same as that for dividend paying stocks.

First, it is important to look for stocks with strong fundamentals. This means researching a company’s financials and performance history, looking for stocks with a strong balance sheet, positive cash flow, and low debt levels. Additionally, some investors will look for stocks with high growth potential and a long-term track record of success.

It is also important to consider the company’s dividends history. Even though the stock is not currently paying dividends, it could be doing so in the future. Look at the company’s dividend policy and whether it is likely to pay out dividends in the future.

My name is Michael. My background is in technology, not finance.

What this means is that my head isn’t filled with high-flying, new-economy financial theory nonsense that universities pump out these days to justify the absurdity of wall street.

What I lack in letters following my name I make up for in experience. 20 years of active investing experience – counting 3 (as of March, 2020) bubbles and subsequent busts, to be exact.

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Mercury Investing is dedicated to providing you with the knowledge to determine the value of a company stock on your own!

No “Hot pick” or “pump-and-dump” penny stock BS!

We will help you cut through the crap found on many investing sites and newsletters, so you can see for yourself whether a company is worth investing your hard-earned money in.

Legal Disclaimers and such..


The information contained on this Website and the resources available for download through this website are for educational and informational purposes only.​


The information contained on this Website and the resources available for download through this website is not intended as, and shall not be understood or construed as, professional advice. While the employees and/or owners of the Company do their best to present accurate and truthful information, the information contained on this Website is not a substitute for advice from a professional who is aware of the facts and circumstances of your individual situation.

We have done our best to ensure that the information provided on this Website and the resources available for download are accurate and provide valuable information. Regardless of anything to the contrary, nothing available on or through this Website should be understood as a recommendation that you should not consult with a professional to address your particular information. The Company expressly recommends that you seek advice from a professional.

Neither the Company nor any of its employees or owners shall be held liable or responsible for any errors or omissions on this website or for any damage you may suffer as a result of failing to seek competent advice from a professional who is familiar with your situation.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *